Choosing Between Submersible and Pedestal Sump Pumps: The Decision That Could Save Your Basement
When it comes to protecting your basement from flooding, choosing the right sump pump design is crucial. Sump pumps are the common go-to for homeowners with frequent flooding complications and can save your basement from permanent damage during a flood. The two main types available—submersible and pedestal sump pumps—each offer distinct advantages and drawbacks that can significantly impact your home’s flood protection.
Understanding the Key Differences
Unlike submersible pumps, which sit underwater in a sump pit, a pedestal pump sits on the floor, such as the basement or crawlspace floor. This fundamental design difference affects everything from installation costs to maintenance requirements and overall performance.
Submersible sump pumps are placed below water at the base of your sump pit, and you’ll need a bigger pit than with a pedestal pump for this reason. Because these pumps and their motors operate underwater, the noise level is reduced, which is a pleasant feature for those who spend time in the basement.
Submersible Sump Pumps: Power and Performance
Submersible pumps are often considered the superior choice for homeowners dealing with significant water issues. Submersible sump pumps are more powerful than pedestal pumps and can pump out solids and debris that may find their way into your sump pit, making them more expensive but greatly worth the investment. For applications where you need to pump water higher than a few feet to get it outside, you’ll benefit from submersible sump pumps that have greater horsepower (HP) ratings and the ability to pump more gallons per hour (GPH) through your system than with a pedestal pump.
If you are comparing the advantages of pedestal vs submersible sump pumps, a submersible pump is designed to make less noise because it operates beneath the water. Since this type of pump is configured below the water, it is less likely to overheat in comparison to other types of sump pumps.
However, submersible pumps come with their challenges. Submersible sump pumps are harder to maintain because of their location both being underground and underwater. This may lead to the system breaking down faster than usual (and faster than a pedestal pump).
Pedestal Sump Pumps: Accessibility and Longevity
Pedestal pumps offer several compelling advantages, particularly for homeowners prioritizing easy maintenance and long-term durability. Pedestal sump pumps are one of the easiest to install and maintain. This gives you easy access to put the pump up, take the pump down, check the pump, or maintain the pump.
One major benefit of a pedestal sump pump is that it can last up to three times as long as a submersible sump pump. They actually tend to last two to three times longer than submersible pumps—especially if you properly maintain them.
The main limitation is power output. The biggest drawback of a pedestal sump pump is the power. These pumps don’t work as hard as submersible sump pumps, which means pedestal pumps take longer to redirect the water out of your home, increasing the risk of water damage.
Making the Right Choice for Your Home
Ultimately, your decision will come down to how large your sump pit is, how high/far you need to pump the water, how much you want to spend, and how much power you’ll need to pump out the water that drains into your pit through your discharge pipe.
Consider a submersible pump if:
- Your basement experiences frequent or heavy flooding
- You have adequate space for a deeper sump pit
- Noise reduction is important for finished basements
- You need to pump water over long distances or significant elevation changes
A pedestal pump may be better if:
- You have a shallow or narrow sump pit
- Easy maintenance access is a priority
- Budget constraints are a primary concern
- Your flooding issues are relatively minor
Professional Installation and Replacement Services
The average cost to replace a sump pump is $309 to $750, though it can range anywhere from $120 to $1,340. The cost mainly depends on the price of the unit and the company you hire to do the replacement. Professional installation ensures proper placement, adequate drainage systems, and optimal performance regardless of which type you choose.
For homeowners in New Jersey dealing with sump pump issues, working with experienced local professionals is essential. Companies like AME Plumbing Heating and Cooling, with years of experience and a dedication to excellence, deliver unmatched expertise and quality service to every homeowner and business, specializing in a wide range of plumbing services and HVAC solutions. Whether you need Sump Pump Replacements in Monmouth County, NJ or are considering upgrading your current system, professional assessment can help determine the best solution for your specific situation.
Ensuring Long-Term Basement Protection
Test your sump pump regularly to ensure it works in an emergency. Granted that your sump pump is properly installed and has the power it needs to function, it can still fail. Regular maintenance, proper installation, and choosing the right pump type for your specific needs are all crucial factors in preventing costly basement flooding.
The decision between submersible and pedestal sump pumps ultimately depends on your home’s specific requirements, budget, and flooding risks. AME Plumbing Heating and Cooling’s commitment to exceeding clients’ expectations means they go above and beyond to ensure that every service call is met with a solution that is both effective and lasting. By carefully evaluating your basement’s unique challenges and consulting with experienced professionals, you can make an informed choice that provides reliable protection for years to come.